Decided to try a new pizza spot today. It’s a casual place with just a few high-top tables inside, but we later discovered there’s a spacious outdoor seating area with umbrellas tucked behind the restaurant. We ordered the curry lemon pepper wings, meatballs, and a Margherita pizza. The wings and meatballs were solid, but the pizza was the real standout—absolutely 5 stars! It’s Neapolitan style, with a thin, chewy crust and nicely blistered, slightly charred edges. We thoroughly enjoyed every bite. Honestly, it’s worth the 25 mile drive just for that pizza. We had a chance to chat with the owner, who shared that he started selling pizza from a food truck back in 2016, and three years ago, he opened this brick-and-mortar location in Riverside. You can really taste the passion and experience in the food.

Wow! I was staying in Jacksonville for work. A few months back I had a horrible pizza experience at a place called V pizza. So I decided I would give Pie95 a try. I am so glad I did. This delicious tasty pizza was absolutely amazing. The employees were extremely friendly. The service was great and I was sitting down eating my delicious pizza in no time. My recommendation if it's your first time is the Margerhita. Just look at that beautiful masterpiece. I can't wait to work in Jacksonville again.

Excellent pizzeria!! Reminded me and my friend of being overseas again. My boyfriend loved the tiramisu. The staff/Owners were very personable. And if they recommend a pie for you to try my advice is do it!!! We will definitely be back soon! Thank you for the wonderful experience.

Absolutely amazing! Pie 95 Pizza is hands down one of the best pizza places I've ever been to. The food was incredible! Evan and the staff are so friendly, and the atmosphere is welcoming, making it a great spot for a casual meal or a special night out. If you're a pizza lover, Pie 95 is a must-visit. Definitely a 5-star experience every time!

Pie 95 is absolutely incredible! The food was amazing—every bite was packed with flavor, and you can truly taste the quality and craftsmanship in their pizzas. The service was just as excellent! Evan and staff were friendly and welcoming, that made the experience even better! If you’re looking for top-notch pizza and outstanding hospitality, this is the place to go. Highly recommend!

Looking for the best wood fired pizza in Jax? We found it at Pie95. These people know their craft, a truly elevated pizza experience. If you feel like a glass of wine or love a cold beer with your pie, they’ve got it. We appreciate the quality ingredients, charming atmosphere and friendly staff. Right now we are looking forward to coming back and trying the rest of the menu.....and have already decided this will also be our take-out option when we have company.

I've been a Pie 95 fan since the Food Truck days. Tonight our entire team had the pleasure of a business dinner in this incredible little hot spot! The vibe and decor is very inviting, cozy, and a perfect reflection of Riverside. We enjoyed the Meatballs, Shrimp, Garlic bread, Arugula salad, Caprese salad, Margherita Pizza and the Bianca. EVERY dish was picture perfect quality, and tasted as decadent and delicious as it arrived on our plates. The crust was absolute perfection, with all the flavor profiles balanced to deliver fresh and satisfying bites of bliss. In short, we had so much fun watching Evan and team do their thing....The pizza making show is fascinating to watch....we are definitely planning to return VERY soon. Highly recommend!!

Super yummy wood fired pizza! We want to devour the entire pie every time. Last week we tried their speciality white pizza with bacon on top and they had a lemon slice for us to use on the pizza. I never saw this before but wow did it give it a special touch!! The meatball apps are also super yummy. They have outdoors seating in the back and lent us a Jenga game to play with our daughter. Love the service and the food!